Metal Roof vs Shingles: The Ultimate Comparison for Peoria Homes

The “Forever Roof” or the “Affordable Classic”?

If you are planning a roof replacement this year, you are likely stuck in the debate every homeowner faces: Metal Roof vs Shingles.

In the past, the choice was easy. Shingles were for houses; metal was for barns. But today, with metal roofing resembling slate, cedar shake, and designer tiles, the line has blurred.

In Central Illinois, where we face everything from softball-sized hail to 60mph wind gusts, choosing the right material is about more than just color—it is about protection. This guide compares metal roofs vs shingles regarding cost, longevity, and ROI specifically for Peoria area homeowners.

The Contenders at a Glance

Before we dive deep, here is the “Tale of the Tape” for our local market:

1. Durability: Dealing with Illinois Weather

When comparing a metal roof vs shingles, you have to talk about the weather.

Asphalt Shingles:

Modern architectural shingles are tough. Most come with wind ratings up to 110mph. However, as they age, they become brittle. In our freeze-thaw cycles, the granules (the sand-like coating) wear off, leaving the matting exposed to the sun. Once that happens, curling and cracking are inevitable.

Metal Roofing:

Metal is the “heavyweight champion” of durability.

• Hail: Most metal roofs have a Class 4 Impact Rating. While hail might dent metal, it rarely punctures it, keeping your home dry when shingles would have failed.

• Snow: Metal sheds snow easily, preventing the heavy buildup that causes roof collapses.

• Fire: Metal is non-combustible, offering the highest level of fire protection for your family.

2. The Cost Factor: Upfront vs. Long-Term

This is usually the deciding factor.

• Shingles: They are the budget-friendly choice. If you plan to move in 5-10 years, or if you are on a strict budget, shingles are the logical path. They offer excellent protection for the price.

• Metal: Expect to pay 2 to 3 times more upfront for a metal roof compared to asphalt. However, because a metal roof can last 50+ years, it is often cheaper in the long run. We call this the “One-and-Done” investment.

3. Aesthetics: The “Barn” Myth

A common fear is, “Will my house look like a shed?”

Technology has changed. [Stone Coated Steel Roofing] offers the best of both worlds: the durability of steel with the look of traditional shingles or tile.

• Shingles: Offer a classic, traditional look that blends into any neighborhood in Peoria.

• Metal: offers a sleek, modern look (Standing Seam) or a rustic aesthetic (Stone Coated).

4. Energy Efficiency

Did you know your roof affects your AC bill?

• Shingles: Dark asphalt shingles absorb heat, radiating it down into your attic. This forces your air conditioner to work harder in July and August.

• Metal: Metal roofs are “cool roofs.” They reflect solar radiant heat, which can reduce cooling costs by 10-25% according to the State Farm Insurance.

The Verdict: Which is Right for You?

Choose Asphalt Shingles If:

• You want the most affordable upfront cost.

• You prefer the traditional look of a standard roof.

• You plan to sell your home in the near future.

• Explore our Shingle Options

Choose Metal Roofing If:

• This is your “forever home” and you never want to re-roof again.

• You want maximum protection against hail and wind.

• You want to lower your monthly cooling bills.

• Explore our Metal Roofing Systems

Still Undecided? See the Difference Yourself.

Pictures can only tell you so much. At SNS Roofing, we can bring samples of both materials to your home so you can see the color and quality against your own siding.

Get an honest quote for both options.

Contact SNS Roofing today for a free consultation and let us help you settle the metal roof vs shingles debate for your home.